IH London teacher Melissa Lamb shares her experience of dealing with the reoccurring 'to' and 'for' question in class, with a little help from Scott Thornbury…
This month I’ve been teaching a lower intermediate class, a level somewhere between pre-intermediate and mid-intermediate. They’re a lovely class, quite strong in terms of fluency, and they are generally looking to increase their range of vocabulary and their accuracy of grammar.
On about the third day of the course, a perennial problem raised its head when Anastasia asked me, “When do you use 'for' and when do you use 'to'?” Not being something that can be dealt with on the spot, I decided to go away and prepare something for them.
What was interesting to me was the idea that 'to' has a forward looking sense to it, except in fixed expressions, and 'for' tends to look backwards over a duration of time.
I took a paragraph from Natural Grammar by Scott Thornbury:
Thornbury, S. (2011) Natural Grammar, Oxford, Oxford University Press, p.165
Reproduced with permission from Oxford University Press
| Prediction and gist task – typical teenage problems
|| To process text for meaning
| Exploration task – inserting examples of 'to' that had been taken out
|| Initial diagnostic, learners using existing language knowledge and recognising gaps in this knowledge
| Hypothesis building – students work together to see if all the examples fit the ‘looking forward’ meaning
|| To clarify meaning and use of 'to'
| Focus on forms – students complete a spider diagram by searching for examples in the text that take a similar pattern
|| To establish the most common patterns used with 'to'. Generate more examples to test the pattern
| Response to text – students write a response providing advice
|| To focus on meaning and provide an opportunity to use the language in an authentic way
| Consolidation – Students use the sentence headers to create interesting questions to ask classmates
|| To encourage fluency and automaticity with the patterns. To give students opportunity to experiment using the patterns with different verbs and question words
| Notebooks – Students share and record the different patterns in their notebooks
|| To encourage recall
The students were very satisfied with this focus because most course books do not help learners categorise patterns. As a result students can be in very high level classes and still not be able to use key words such as 'for' and 'to'.
Students like patterns more than rules
I find Natural Grammar a really helpful resource for identifying patterns with the top 100 most frequent words in English.
Learners tend to find patterns helpful because unlike rules, they are generative. They were most interested in the fact that there was an overriding sense or meaning to 'to' and that there are certain verbs and nouns that are more likely to collocate with 'to' and that these can be categorised by their meanings.
The next week we went on to look at 'for' and we were able to contrast this with 'to'.
Obviously it’s difficult to say whether they are more accurate now but I would argue that by doing tasks like this you can raise awareness and if the learners are at the right developmental stage foster intake.
I also recommend looking at chapter 7 of Rules, Patterns and Words by Dave Willis (CEP, 2003).
Have a go, and let me know what you think.
CELTA, CLTA and CPD
At IH London we have training courses for English and European language teaching and career development.
Whether you're new to language teaching, want to take your expertise to the next level or would like to develop your language teaching skills in a specific area we can proved the courses and training you need.